Partscaster wrote: ↑Mon Sep 06, 2021 1:42 pm
All things being unequal, I really enjoy being able to pick up similar strat builds with a different awesome flavor of pickups in them. Or same model pickups, similar body, but different neck varieties, etc. Its way nicer than actually changing pups in and out to make any comparisons. At some point I'll sell most off. But I'll have had a great set of options to test side by side, and choose a few keepers from.
Hanging onto some favorite pickups may be a good investment. DAllen has perhaps stopped building. I bet his pickups will gain in value, as they are on the top of many's favorites list (not my favorites list, though. I have 4 sets to eventually sell). Chubtone has fetched big money and he is scarcely winding. If Klein stops winding, those pickups will become worth more, IMO. The sad part would be them not being readily available if I needed to replace a set.
2 more strats, and I'm done.
Haha... Yeah, we really need to start telling ourselves that pickups are an
investment.

Unfortunamtely, I don't have many booteek-type pickups. Just the Brandonwound, and a few Buddhas. I also have a killer set of Strat pickups by US Toneworks in the Sun King, but I wouldn't call them "boutique" (I only paid $50 for the set!). The rest that I have are all commercially made pickups.
Personally, I like all my guitars to sound noticeably different. I don't like redundancy. I'm a Tele nut, but I only own two in the traditional pickup configuration. They sound different enough from each other... well... the neck pickups do. The bridge pickups sound different, but not by much. So I don't really feel the urge to own another Tele in that config (unless something totally irresistible comes along, that is

), because they'll just be slight variations, and I already like what I have. The rest of my Teles have non-Tele pickups in them.
I could never understand owning multiples of the same guitar, all with the same
type of pickups (let alone same brand/model), that all sound only slightly different from each other. If it were me, I'd naturally gravitate to the one I think sounds best and the rest of them would go unplayed. I now have two Strats, and as soon as I finished the Sun King, I could already tell that the other one was going to get neglected. It sounds good, and it sounds different, just not different enough... And the Sun King sounds better (to me). If I build another Strat, it'll probably have P90s or something... Then again, if I didn't find LPs uncomfortable to play, I probably wouldn't feel the need so much to put HBs and P90s into Fender-style guitars...
It's complicated.
